Talk:Battle for Canada

Read your timeline and I just have a few comments and questions:
 * What exactly is the POD?
 * The term "Battle for Canada" is inaccurate since only the Province of Canada (Upper and Lower Canada, or Ontario and Quebec later) was called Canada at this time. Halifax was part of the colony of Nova Scotia, Vancouver of British Colombia.
 * A British retreat into the Arctic seems unlikely. No one (that they cared about) lived there, there was no economical value to the place. Plus Iqaluit wasn't founded until 1942.  Its more likely the Royal Navy (the largest and most powerful at the time) would just take them back to Britain or some other southern colony if they went anywhere.  Also how did the Americans get there without freezing to death?
 * The British had a large army at this time, which was not as affected by the war in Europe than other armies. If Napoleon was defeated in 1815 in this timeline, then the British would not have a shortage of troops to send to Canada. For an example you may want to check out Short-lived US, an unintentional mirror universe to your TL.  Mitro 01:44, 23 June 2009 (UTC)