Talk:The Unlikely Alliance

This a very interesting idea, and not unlike an ATL I had been considering making it. If I may, though, there are two bits of constructive criticism I'd like to make: Anyway, I do think that this is a really great idea, but it has issues. If you're willing, I'd be happy to actively play a part in editing, but I fully respect your wishes to keep this timeline your own. Fegaxeyl 17:27, June 21, 2010 (UTC)
 * The war, at least in Germany, seems totally mirrored. It's just what happened in Russia stamped onto Germany. Though this is interesting it isn't particularly realistic (especially with ethnic-based mass murders; that's just not communist).
 * In relation to the above point, it says Germany took 27 million casualties. Possible, given how much of the war was fought there, but 27 million people is well over half of 1939 Germany. The people would probably force a surrender, and even then, the country would scarcely exist after the war. Russia could sustain 27 million casualties because of the fact it had hundreds of millions more citizens to fall back on. I would imagine Germany could probably take at most 10-15 million casualties before collapsing, but that's still a worst-case scenario number.