User blog comment:Scrawland Scribblescratch/Presidential Stuff/@comment-32656-20120902032812/@comment-32656-20120902083409

That stuff isn't at all relevant.

Smith is one of the problems. There is no way on earth he gets elected then. 1930s? Maybe. But not in that era. I mean, he was not even quite eligible for the presidency in 1908 by election time. And only slightly better in 1912. It's just not possible. His religion has not one iota to do with the problem.

James Knox Taylor has an error of some sort on your list.

And you have FDR with how many terms? Some of which would be after his death. Same applies to Cordell Hull.