User blog comment:Bobalugee1940/Estates-General for the USA/@comment-32656-20121002192704

No all around.

The Quebecois never lived under the Estates General, never voted, etc. Most would not even know what it was.

They also are so small in number that they aren't going to be revolting, let alone having any success. Heck, even before the Brits got all nice to them they were better off then they had been under the French government.

And there is no way on earth that the American colonists would agree to such a thing involving religion.

A "King" would not happen.

Add to that that the American colonists and the Quebecois are primarily different religions - and cannot stand each other.

Really, the idea that they would have joined the revolt is always overrated. Just wouldn't really happen, and there's no way that they could manage the task even if all of them rose up.

There's also how many "what-ifs" in that?