Talk:Timeline (Godfrey Raphael Universe)

Impossible for the Finns to do that. Simple question of numbers. The Soviet reasons for wanting more land remain, as well. WWII happens, but with all v.s. USSR instead of Nazis.

Himmler was nowhere near the position of Fueher, and would not have gotten the position. And him acting like a regular world leader and not invading, etc. others makes little sense.

Hitler's was also nuts, so the premise that he would care about a slaughter is... tenuous at best. This is man who had long advocated mass killings by that point.

Why would the Japanese, and others, re-join the League? Germany, maybe, but the rest? Their reasons for leaving had nothing to do with Versailles.

Why on earth would the Poles attack Germany territory? That makes absolutely no sense. I could see them seizing Danzig, maybe, but even that makes little sense when it would get them no gain whatsoever.

Considering how many carriers existed at the time, it is completely impossible for Filipinos to get one, let alone the pilots, crews, fuel, and ammunition to do such a thing, and somehow not get noticed. And, they were supposed to get independence very shortly, anyways. Why on earth would anyone mess with that? The Filipino troops were all loyal, and Jose P. Laurel was not actually a rebel or separatist, either, and would not have done that, nor would he have had any real support.

Why would the Czechs do something like attack Germany, a nation several times their size and strength? The makes no sense. Nor would an assassination of a German official in the Sudetenland, a German-speaking area, make much sense, especially by the Czechs.

Fascist support is strongest in the south. Why would they go to the north? That only happened in otl because the Allies were in the south. Not because of where they could actually get support.

American Troops? And in support of Royalists? That's not possible.

Estonia is several countries and a few hundred miles away from Danzig or East Prussia. Not possible, not would they care. Lithuania might make sense, but they'd be helping to Poles to get their own claims in East Prussia for themselves.

East Prussia was an integral part of Germany, not independent in any way. The Poles would have lost any conflict between the two.

The Warshaw Uprising part makes no sense at all. Nor does the last Phillipines section.

And all that ignores the Soviets invading and conquering Europe while everyone else does nothing.

Intriguing opening concept with Hitler having the dream, mind - he did believe in signs of that nature, big-time. But it reads like you've taken WWII events and turned them into things that make no sense.

Lordganon 18:52, August 31, 2011 (UTC)