Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-4780584-20121224153803/@comment-1310192-20130103023312

GunsnadGlory wrote:

Runaway bride was fun. -_-

Right, I forgot about christmas Carol, that was good.

Doctor, Widow, Wardrobe was TERRIBLE.

See, the thing is, Smith has the better companions and the better scripter. Think about it; Rose was idioitic, Martha was ok, and Donna was a bit of a joke. Amy and Rory? Craig? The best companions in the new series, easily. And Davies has his bright sparks, but Moffat is consistently brilliant- think about Blink, arguably one of Tennant's best. But just in the portrayal of the Doctor- Tennant wins.

That's just me, I have weird Doctor Who tastes. :P

I liked Doctor Widow and Wardrobe and HATED Donna in Runaway. The plot was meh, Donna was arrogant and idiotic and she is a very fun companion otherwise so I was disappointed.

Well yes, I agree with you; Tennant is the better Doctor, but Smith's episodes are far better.