Alternative History
1852 United States presidential election
← 1848 November 2, 1852 1856 →

296 members of the Electoral College
149 electoral votes needed to win
Opinion polls
Turnout 69.5% 3.3 pp
  Winfield Scott by Fredricks, 1862 (cropped) Franklin Pierce Vice-President 1852
Nominee Winfield Scott Franklin Pierce
Party Whig Democratic
Home state New Jersey New Hampshire
Running mate Stephen Douglas DeVane King
Electoral vote 149 147
States carried 15 16
Popular vote 1,566,305 1,428,159
Percentage 52.3% 47.7%

1852 Alt Election (So Help Us God)
Presidential election results map. Yellow denotes states won by Scott/Douglas and blue denotes those won by Pierce/King. Numbers indicate electoral votes cast by each state.

President before election

Zachary Taylor
Whig

Elected President

Winfield Scott
Whig

The 1852 United States presidential election was the 17th quadrennial presidential election, held on Tuesday, November 2, 1852. Whig nominee General Winfield Scott defeated Democrat Franklin Pierce.

General Zachary Taylor had come to the presidency in 1849. Taylor endorsed the Compromise of 1850 and its Fugitive Slave Law. This earned Taylor some Southern voter support and Northern voter opposition, as well as Northern voter support and Southern voter opposition, though he did not run for a second term. Scott won the nomination following the dropout of former vice president Henry Seward and death of former vice president Daniel Webster. Democrats divided among four major candidates at the 1852 Democratic National Convention. On the 49th ballot, dark horse candidate Franklin Pierce won nomination by consensus compromise.

With few policy differences between the two major candidates, the election became a personality contest. Though Scott had commanded in the Mexican–American War, Pierce also served. Scott strained Whig Party unity as his anti-slavery reputation gravely damaged his campaign in the South, but he made up for it with his vice presidential pick being Illinois Democrat Stephen Douglas.

Pierce and running mate DeVane King won a comfortable popular majority, carrying 16 of the 31 states. Anti-slavery Whigs and Free Soilers, a third party based on anti-slavery, would ultimately coalesce into the new Republican Party, which would quickly become a formidable movement in the free states.

Nominations[]

Whig Primary[]

Candidates[]

Nominee[]

Candidate Born Home state Most recent position States won
Winfield Scott by Fredricks, 1862 (cropped)

Winfield Scott

June 13, 1786 (age 66)

Petersburg, Virginia, U.S.

New Jersey 3rd Commanding General of the United States Army VT, MA, RI, DE, MD, VA, NC, GA, TN, KY, OH, IN, IL, IA, LA

Withdrew or Died during the Primaries[]

Candidate Born Home state Most recent position States won
Zachary Taylor (1849-1853)

Zachary Taylor

November 24, 1784 (aged 67)

Barboursville, Virginia, U.S.

Louisiana 12th President of the United States None
Daniel Webster Photograph edited

Daniel Webster

January 18, 1782

Salisbury, New Hampshire, U.S.

Massachusetts 14th and 19th Secretary of State Died October 24, 1852 (aged 70)

Whig Primary[]

Candidates[]

Nominee[]

Candidate Born Home state Most recent position States won
Franklin Pierce Vice-President 1852

Franklin Pierce

November 23, 1804 (age 47)

Hillsborough, New Hampshire, U.S.

New Hampshire Senator of New Hampshire ME, NH, CT, NY, PA, NJ, GA, FL, AL, MI, AK, MO, MI, WI, TX, CA

Withdrew or Lost during the Primaries[]

Candidate Born Home state Most recent position States won
Lewis Cass circa 1855

Lewis Cass

October 9, 1782 (age 70)

Exeter, New Hampshire, U.S.

Michigan Senator of Michigan None
James Buchanan President (1857-1861)

James Buchanan

April 23, 1791 (age 61)

Cove Gap, Pennsylvania, U.S.

Pennsylvania 17th Secretary of State None
William L. Marcy - Brady-Handy

William Marcy

December 12, 1786 (age 65)

Southbridge, Massachusetts, U.S.

New Yorm 20th Secretary of War None

Chosen as vice during the primaries[]

Candidate Born Home state Most recent position States won
Stephen A. Douglas trying 1852

Stephen Douglas

April 23, 1813 (age 39)

Brandon, Vermont, U.S.

Illinois Senator of Illinois None


Election[]

When American voters went to the polls, Scott won the electoral college in a close vote, though Pierce won a majority of the key states. In the popular vote, while Scott outpolled Pierce by roughly 100,000 votes, Pierce carried 16 states as opposed to the close margin brought upon by Scott's 15. Scott's presidency is what kept the Whigs together, though after the diving presidency of Taylor, the Whigs continued to quarrel in constant inhouse fighting until they eventually went their separate ways - the Republican Party emerged out of a majority of the remaining Whigs, and so began the Democratic-dominated South and Republican-dominated North.