Alternative History
United States presidential election, 1876
← 1872 November 7, 1876 (1876-11-07) 1880 →

301 members of the Electoral College
120 electoral votes needed to win
  Samuel Tilden. Portrait of the American politician, who served as the 25th Governor of New York, Samuel Jones Tilden (1814-1886), by José María Mora, c. 1870 (cropped) Rutherford B. Hayes Benjamin Bristow
Nominee Samuel J. Tilden Rutherford B. Hayes Benjamin Bristow
Party Democratic Republican Independent
Home state New Netherland Ohio Centralia
Running mate Thomas A. Hendricks Chester A. Arthur George Henry Williams
Electoral vote 246 44 8
States carried 20 2 1
Popular vote 4,286,8082 1,034,142 1,004,217
Percentage 50.9% 23.1% 20.4%

  Jan Heemskerk Azn (1818-1897), after Heinrich Wilhelm Wollrabe
Nominee Jan Heemskerk
Party Independent
Home state New Netherland
Running mate Gerlach Cornelis Joannes van Reenen
Electoral vote 3
States carried 1
Popular vote 943,381
Percentage 5.6%

1976electionahr2
Electoral College results

President before election

George H. Pendleton
Democratic

Elected President

Samuel J. Tilden
Democratic

The 1876 United States presidential election was the 23rd quadrennial presidential election, held on Tuesday, November 7, 1876. Incumbent President George H. Pendleton opted not to run again for a third elected term, leading the race open to multiple candidates. The election saw a Republican split that guaranteed the Democrats a victory. As of 2024, this is also the last election in which there was more than one candidate not affiliated with any political party or organization.

The Democratic Party, under control of the Bourbon faction, nominated New Netherland Governor Samuel J. Tilden, with Thomas A. Hendricks as his running mate. The Republicans, still fractured due to their association with the loss in the Second Columbian War, struggled to mount an effective campaign. They nominated the moderate Rutherford B. Hayes, who was a veteran of the war, provoking a split from the pro-civil rights and New Netherland chapters of the party. On one hand, the party's Stalwart faction opposed Hayes for his leniency on debate for civil service reform and civil rights, and on another, the New Netherland faction opposed Hayes due to his controversial proposal to block migrations of Dutch speakers outside of New Netherland. Thus, the Republicans were split three ways, leaving the election results firmly in the hands of the Democrats once again. Nonetheless, Hayes mounted a widespread campaigning tour in comparison to the three other candidates, visiting as far as Kosuto to gain the support of both Republicans and Democrats alike.

As expected, Tilden won the election in a landslide, cementing control of the party's Bourbon faction and cementing the party's final electoral victory during their 12-year streak of winning the presidency, which was ended by Roscoe Conkling four years later.